Book Review: City of Spies by Susan Kim and Laurance Klavan

During the early days the U.S. was involved in Word War II, Americans became obsessed with the thought that spies were among them, secreting away information that would aid the enemy and defeat the Allies. In New York, people were suspicious of Germans in general, and many thought it was their patriotic duty to keep an eye on German citizens.

This is the setting for City of Spies, a new graphic novel by Susan Kim and Laurance Klavan, with artwork by Pascal Dizin. Evelyn has arrived to spend the summer with her Aunt Lia in New York while her father spends time with his new wife. An only child, Evelyn has known a series of stepmothers since her own mother died years before. To help pass the time, she draws action adventures for the superhero she creates, Zirconium Man, and she is his sidekick, Scooter.

Aunt Lia’s artistic lifestyle doesn’t accommodate Evelyn very well, but she doesn’t mind as much after she meets the building superintendent’s son, Tony. Together, they decide to have an adventure and catch a spy. They soon discover that just because someone has a German background, it doesn’t mean he’s stealing secrets and working with the enemy. When they stumble on a real plot, they decide to follow it through and foil the bad guys themselves.

City of Spies does a great job of exploring the imagined and real dangers of the early 1940s while focusing on issues such as friendship, family relationships, and loneliness for both children and adults. It also brings to life two fantasies common among children: being a superhero and catching a spy. As in all good graphic novels, much of the plot and action are carried through by the artwork, and Dizin’s drawings are the perfect accompaniment to Kim and Klavan’s words. A mother-daughter book club with girls aged 13 and up would be able to discuss the historic era and how graphic novels in general differ from reading a regular novel.

Interview with Kathleen Kent, Author of The Heretic’s Daughter

Kathleen Kent

Kathleen Kent is the author of The Heretic’s Daughter, a story of the Carrier family and the Salem Witch Trials (see my review). She grew up in Dallas before attending the University of Texas at Austin.  After college she moved to New York where she worked in commodities and then as a contractor for the U.S. Department of Defense, traveling extensively in the Former Soviet Union.

In 2000 she returned with her family to Dallas and began writing the book she had always wanted to write; the story of Martha Carrier, the author’s grandmother back 9 generations, who was hanged as a witch in Salem in 1692. Her first novel, The Heretic’s Daughter, is based in part on those family stories, passed down through many generations and has been a New York Times bestselling novel, both in hardcover and in paperback.  Published in over a dozen countries, it was the recipient of the 2008 David J. Langum award for American historical fiction.  Ms. Kent’s second novel, The Wolves of Andover, about the life of Thomas Carrier, will be published by Little Brown in November of 2010.

I caught up to Kent by email, where she happily answered a few questions for Mother Daughter Book Club.com.

I understand you got the idea for The Heretic’s Daughter from family stories about Martha Carrier. How did you decide to turn those stories into a novel?

I first remember hearing about Martha Carrier and the Carrier family legends from my grandmother. She told such wonderful stories, not only about the Salem witch trials, but about the hardships and personal courage of Martha and her husband Thomas. She was the one who said, in answer to my question of whether or not Martha was truly witch, “there are no such things as witches, merely ferocious women!” I had always had in mind to write a fictionalized version of these events, but ended up working for twenty years in New York, building a career in business. In 2000, when I moved back to my childhood home of Dallas, I made a conscious decision to begin the research and writing of the book. It took five years of hard research and many drafts of the novel before I felt confident enough to send it to publishers.

How difficult was it for you to imagine the details of life for these people, your ancestors who became your characters?

When I first began researching the book, I felt very strongly that for the story to feel authentic, it needed to be filled with accurate accounts of day to day life; how these settlers dressed, farmed, cared for their families, worshipped. I spent countless hours pouring over documents, sermons and letters of the day to glean details of what life was like in 17th century New England. The best historical fiction, I believe, is anchored in good historical research. The characters were drawn not only from the stories that my grandmother used to tell—she was always gleeful about how outspoken Martha Carrier was—but also from relatives in my own immediate family. The story of conflict between Sarah and her mother, Martha, were drawn, in part, to my own struggles to find self-identity. And finally, I was very fortunate to have access to the verbatim transcripts of some of the court proceedings. A lot of the state of mind and character of the accused can be extracted from the narrative of the actual trials.

What kind of research did you do to fill in the other historical information you needed to bring your story to life?

I did a lot of conventional research in books and on-line as there is a wealth of fiction and non-fiction information of the time in print, but I also traveled to Massachusetts and Connecticut to visit historical societies, genealogical societies and even senior citizen homes to talk to the local town historians. Standing in the original buildings and homes that still exist gave me a visceral sense of the scale and harshness of the times, and I looked for lesser known (and sometimes very dry) accounts of agrarian life in the 17th century. Some of the best windows into the times came from reading the letters of the settlers, although most of the accounts were from the male perspective of Puritan life.

Did you discover anything surprising while you were conducting research?

It came as a surprise that close to 150 men,women and children under the age of 17 were arrested, some of whom were relatively privileged and influential. When we study the witch trials in school, we usually tend to believe that only a hand full of people were accused and hanged.  So many theories have been offered to explain the intensity of the hysteria—ergot poisoning, or even that there really was witchcraft practiced—but I was surprised to learn that almost every accusing girl had been related to, or closely associated with, someone who had been captured or killed by Indians. In the Puritan mind the native Americans were not devils figuratively, but were in essence devils personified. It gave me a new perspective on the level of fear the settlers experienced waiting for the next raid or attack.

How did you decide to tell the story from Sarah’s point of view, instead of her mother’s?

I had originally planned to write the book from Martha’s point of view, but I quickly realized that once Martha is hanged, that’s the end of her narrative. There was so much that happened after the hangings, so many young people still imprisoned, that I decided it would be more interesting to have the narrator be one of Martha’s children. In reality, four of her five children were arrested, her two oldest sons tortured to compel them to testify against their own mother, and I felt that the story would take on a new, deeper emotional charge if it was told by the young daughter, Sarah.

I also wanted to illustrate the universal, and timeless, theme of the dynamics between mothers and daughters. It usually takes a life-time of living, raising children, marriage, and profound loss, to fully understand the sacrifices that our mothers made for us. I wanted to portray a coming of age story, and the blossoming of  personal wisdom that reminds us daily who we are and where we came from.

What do you particularly find fascinating about the Salem Witch Trials?

There are so many elements of the trials that are interesting, not just from a historical point of view, but which have relevence today; religious tolerance and freedom, the necessity of due process of law, engaging in the greater civilized discuss to prevent abuses of power, especially from fundamentalist groups who seek to repress the weakest members of society, mostly women and children. I think for a long time, quite a few people still wanted to believe that these so-called witches were in fact confederates of the Devil. There is a profound longing for magic in our lives and it’s titillating to think of people with the power to fly on a broomstick, casting magical spells. But with good historical scrutiny comes revelation, and we only have to look back a little ways in more recent history—Bosnia in the 1980’s, Germany in the 1930’s—to see how quickly, even the most “enlightened”, civilization can turn on its own people. We now know that the men and women hanged were victims of greed, vengeful thinking, unreasoning supersitious fear and a misunderstanding of mental illness.

How does this story differ from others told about that time?

It is, at heart, a story of family struggle, courage and survival. The witch trials are an important part of the book, indeed its central theme, but it’s a more personal story about the Carrier family–stories that have been passed down through ten generations. There are little anecdotal tales in the book that come directly from the family, for example the Carrier cow that was fed pumpkins and gave golden milk, that I hoped would give a greater dimension to the characters. A lot of the fictionalized versions of the witch trials center on the trials, without chronicling the events that led up to the hysteria and neighbor turning against neighbor.

What are you working on now?

I am delighted to say that I have completed the prequel to The Heretic’s Daughter which will be released on November 8. Titled The Wolves of Andover, the novel depicts the life of Thomas Carrier, Martha’s husband, and his involvement in the English Civil War and the events leading to the execution of King Charles I of England. Some of his life previous to coming to the colonies was alluded to in the first novel. The contents of the “red diary” will be fully revealed, exposing the intrigue and mayhem of the courts of Charles I and Charles II, and the flight of the regicides to the new world.

Is there anything else you’d like to say to readers at Mother Daughter Book Club.com?

One of my greatest joys since publishing The Heretic’s Daughter is knowing that so many women have shared the book with their families, especially with their mothers, daughters, grandmothers, etc. I have spoken to many book groups, and often the most fun are the mother/daughter book clubs where the readers tell their own generational stories. The book has been published in 15 countries, worldwide, and it speaks to the importance of the women bonding together for support and comfort. After all, usually the keepers of the flame of family history are the women.

Book Review: The Heretic’s Daughter by Kathleen Kent

When hardship hits ten-year-old Sarah Carrier’s family, they move on a cold December day from their home in Billerica, Massachusetts to nearby Andover. They don’t know it, but they carry the plague with them, wrapped in the blankets her brother shivers into. The Carriers move in with Sarah’s grandmother, and they must apply to the local council for the right to stay. Everyone is afraid of the plague, but in deference to Sarah’s grandmother the family is allowed to stay—to dire consequences. When it’s clear the sickness is in their home, Sarah and her younger sister are sent to live with an aunt and uncle until the worst has passed. Months later, they return home to find their brothers, mother and father have survived, but their grandmother has not.

Sarah’s mother, Martha Carrier, is a hard woman who keeps her emotions under tight control. Sarah resents the lack of affection she feels from her mother, and she chafes against the hard life she must live for the family to survive. The Carriers are also isolated, resented by the people of Andover , who blame them for bringing the plague to town. Martha’s hard personality doesn’t soften their resentment.

When things go wrong with crops, or a neighbor’s cow sickens and dies, it’s easy for the superstitious among the Andover populace to lay the blame on Martha. Many whisper that she is a witch to be feared. When girls from the neighboring town of Salem begin to accuse their own townspeople of witchcraft, it’s not long before accusations are aimed at residents of nearby towns as well, and Martha Carrier finds herself accused.

As Sarah slowly watches each of her family members arrested on accusations of witchcraft, she knows the day will come when she has to follow her mother’s instructions to save whoever of the family she can, betraying her mother so the rest may survive.

The Heretic’s Daughter by Kathleen Kent does a masterful job of capturing the mood of the times leading up to and during the Salem Witch Trials. The story of the trials may seem like familiar literary territory, but the author finds a way to make the story fresh as she tells the story of Martha Carrier, one of the many women and men hanged as witches in Salem in 1692.

Carrier was Kent’s ancestor, and Kent grew up hearing family stories of the witch trials as well as Carrier’s place in them. In addition, she conducted extensive research of her own, rooting out official records from the time and finding out details to place the witch hysteria in historic context. She does an excellent job of weaving in details about fears of Indian raids, the plague and harsh winters. It’s hard for us to imagine the hysteria that not only allowed belief in the false claims of girls who claimed that hundreds of citizens roamed the countryside enchanting the people, but also condemned people to die for those claims. The Heretic’s Daughter can prompt discussions of how mass hysteria can take hold of a population, relationships between mothers and daughters, maintaining integrity when faced with hardship. Highly recommended for mother-daughter book clubs with girls aged 14 and up.

Save

Book Review: The Threadbare Heart by Jennie Nash

In The Threadbare Heart, Jennie Nash has written a story of love, loss, family and the many forms each of those can take. There’s love for a lifetime, love to help you heal, parental love, and love found when and where it’s least expected. Loss comes from death, withdrawal of affection, and unmet expectations.

Running through the core of the story is the relationship between Lily and her mother, Eleanor. They are totally opposite in many ways: Lily has had a lifelong love, and Eleanor never felt a strong enough connection with anyone to form a permanent attachment. Lily loves to sew, and she collects fabric to make clothes and quilts for the ones she loved. Embarrassed by her own mother’s homemade clothes, Eleanor doesn’t understand Lily’s lack of desire for designer clothing.

When Lily and Eleanor are forced by tragedy to take on a bigger role in each other’s lives, they struggle to bridge their differences and learn to respect each other for the unique talents they each have. The Threadbare Heart is told from multiple perspectives, including Lily’s husband, Tom, and their sons and daughter in law. This helps the reader see all sides to the story. It’s a reminder that most situations don’t feature good guys and bad guys, just people with different ideas of how they want to live their lives.

In some ways I felt the ending to The Threadbare Heart was abrupt—I could have easily followed Lily and Eleanor’s story for many more chapters—but when I finished it I found myself wondering what would happen next in each of the character’s lives. I worried for them, and I hoped for their futures. I expect the issues brought up in the book will stay with me for a long time.

While older teens may appreciate reading The Threadbare Heart, I believe it’s a better read for adult mothers and their adult daughters. It should open interesting lines of conversation between them about their own relationships. You can still be entered to win copies of this book for your book club by commenting on your favorite fictional mother-daughter pair. (See earlier post.) Comments made before Friday, May 6 at midnight (PDT), will be eligible.

Save

Book Review: The Girls from Ames by Jeffrey Zaslow

The Girls from Ames follows the 40-year friendship of 11 women from Ames, Iowa. Though they are now living in places all over the country, these women have continued to nurture the friendship they built in their school days. They have been available to support each other during the high points of their lives as well as when they faced personal crises.

While I was not always interested in the details of these women’s lives—after all how many of us can say that what we liked in high school would be fascinating for others to read about—I was struck by the value their friendship has brought them in so many ways.

The topics of friendship, family, personal response to tragedy and having a place to call home are prominent throughout The Girls from Ames. Stories are told about the girls and women as individuals, and to illustrate the role they each play as a member of the group.

When I started reading the story, I worked hard to keep track of each woman and her circumstances, but I soon came to feel that each person’s importance is more as a representation of the kind of person she is than as an individual in this specific group. Often, things they said or did reminded me of people I know in my own life.

In the end I felt The Girls from Ames by Jeffrey Zaslow provides a way for us to reflect on and talk about the value of long-time friendship in our lives. I believe it should prompt discussions within a mother-daughter book clubs with girls aged 16 and up about their own relationships.

Book Review: Resistance, Book 1 by Carla Jablonski and Leland Purvis

Paul and Marie Tessier live in a small village in southern France during World War II. While not officially occupied by Germany, Germans are all around them. They worry for their Jewish friend Henri. Then Henri’s parents go missing while he is away from home, and Paul and Marie find themselves hiding their friend while becoming a small part of the French Resistance.

Resistance, Book 1 by Carla Jablonski and Leland Purvis is the first in a series of three graphic novels for young adults. It does an excellent job portraying the confusion, fear and uncertainty that were all part of everyday life at the time. Even young children saw friends turn on each other, and they had a hard time knowing who they could confide in. Members of the Resistance took great risks upon themselves and their families to do what they considered to be right. Strict secrecy meant sometimes even family members didn’t know they were each involved.

So many books about World War II are written for adults; Resistance, Book 1 should be a great book to introduce this historical event to young adults. The images enrich the story beautifully and help keep the action moving along. The author’s note at the back gives a brief description of the Resistance in France that should help fuel discussions. Issues include looking at war-time realities, deciding how much you are willing to risk to help your friends, and determining what you will do to resist something you consider wrong. I highly recommend it for mother-daughter book clubs with girls aged 13 and up.

Interview with Jo Maeder, Author of When I Married My Mother

Jo Maeder is the author of a memoir about the time she spent caring for her aging mother. It’s called When I Married My Mother: A Daughter’s Search for What Really Matters—and How She Found It Caring for Mama Jo. I recently read and reviewed When I Married My Mother, and I’ve been recommending it to everyone I know since. I really think lots of women will find Maeder’s story inspiring, and I asked if she could answer a few questions for readers at Mother Daughter Book Club.com. Here’s the interview.

Joe Maeder photo

Joe Maeder with Mama Jo

You faced a lot of challenges in getting everything set up to take care of Mama Jo. What was one of the biggest?

JM: Looking back, the hardest part was dealing with my mother’s decline long distance and trying to figure out what to do. My mother was also a hoarder who refused to throw out one thing, let a stranger in to help, or relocate. She was in Richmond, VA, I was in the New York City area, and my brother was 4 hours from Mama Jo in Greensboro, NC. We relied on her neighbor and best friend a lot but there’s only so much they could do, or we could ask them to do. In the book I talk about how I convinced her to give me Power of Attorney and the ordeal of getting her moved to Greensboro—where I also moved. I called it Operation Mama Jo because it felt like a military maneuver. It took a Herculean effort by many to accomplish our mission. But it was so worth it!

Moving from a Manhattan lifestyle to a life in small town North Carolina must have been a huge change for you. What do you miss most about your old city life? What was a pleasant surprise about your new town?

JM: There’s so much I don’t miss about New York: the high cost of living, the swearing, the horrible winters, the ordeal of just parking your car. What I do miss are my friends and the socializing, and the unmistakable energy of the northeast in general and the city in particular. What surprised me the most about living in the South was how charmed I was by the people I met everywhere I went. There’s definitely an “Andy of Mayberry” undertone but there’s also a sophisticated vibrancy I didn’t expect.

How was your perception of what life would be like taking care of your mother different from the reality?

JM: It was completely different. She became the sweetest, funniest person and I smoothed out a lot of my rough edges, too. The things I thought would be a problem, like her hoarding, her anger, her inability to get anywhere on time, were not issues at all. Problems I never dreamed would come up—snakes, the giant jumping wolf spider, bats, septic coming up in the front yard—were the stressors.

There must have been many days you wondered whether changing your life to care for your mother was worth it. How did you get through those?

JM: I never doubted it. After three years, though, I did begin to wonder if I would still feel that way if she lived another ten years. It was extraordinarily fulfilling but all-consuming, too. Now I wish she had lived longer. I miss her so much. Our time together was some of the best years of my life. And we had pretty much gone our separate ways when I was 14. That was probably why it was so good. We had a lot of catching up to do.

Do you have any advice for others who are considering caring for an elderly parent?

JM: I know most people can’t do what I did – leave their present lives and move somewhere else to care for a parent while working from home. What’s important is that resentment doesn’t fester. If you can’t handle it, don’t feel guilty about it. You’ll have to make hard choices. You’re not alone. I have some specific eldercare tips on my site at: http://www.jomaeder.com/links/elderly

Is there anything else you would like to say to readers at Mother Daughter Book Club.com?

JM: One thing that became clear to me is that even if you have plenty of money in your old age to hire caregivers (which my mother did not), you still need someone you can trust to manage everything from doctor appointments to hair cuts to helping you stay in touch with your friends. All you can do is show kindness and compassion throughout your life and pray that it will come back to you.

The other point I’d like to make is how deeply I regret not getting over my Mother Issues a lot sooner. I know we both had to surrender to get to this wonderful place where we could love each other and enjoy each other’s company, but I still wish it hadn’t taken so long. I hope any Mother/Daughters reading When I Married My Mother will find that it opens up a dialog between them that perhaps they’ve been avoiding, from misunderstandings to the practical end-of-life issues. One young woman told me, “I had a great conversation with my mother after I read your book about her stuff—what she wants me to keep and what the stories are.” That made me smile. In the end, all we have are our stories. The time I had with Mama Jo gave me an amazing one.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...