Penelope arrives at Anaximander’s Academy, where students learn about and apply the lessons of the Greek mythology to their own lives. She expects to be chosen for the house of Athena, where all of her family before her resided during their years at the school. Instead, she ends up in Aphrodite, which is way too emotional for her practical sense.
As Penelope is tested again and again with events that push her to the limits, she realizes that no other students are experiencing the things she is, and surviving her first year will take all her strength and wits. The Aftermyth by Tracy Wolff is the first in a series for middle grade readers who are interested in stories of mythology set during modern times.
I was attracted to the premise of a girl who arrives at school expecting that she knows how her life will play out over the next six years only to discover that nothing is going as planned and she has to rely on skills and strengths she didn’t realize she had. But I was disappointed in many facets of the story. While I expected action to unfold over the course of Penelope’s first year, over half of the book was dedicated to the first two days. I found myself skipping over descriptions of the challenges she faced because they became repetitive.
There are some cool details about the school, like the fact that campus shifts every night and students have to use their knowledge of it to find their way to classes. But I also felt information about the school and the reason students attended (other than legacy) was lacking. And I never understood the reason Penelope is set apart from others and singled out for the events that happen to her from the time she arrives. The ending, when it comes relatively soon in the book after the first couple of days, felt disconnected, as it was supposed to be months later.
No doubt many middle grade readers will be attracted to the adventures Penelope faces and not be put off by the lack of world building and depth to the story. Those readers aged 9 to 11 should give The Aftermyth a try.
The publisher provided a copy of this title in exchange for my honest review.







